Parent Information, The Montessori Method

Freedom & Limits: from birth to 18 years old


In this blog post you will find my notes from the 2024 Nienhuis Retreat and the lectures from some of Europe’s best AMI Trainers from 0-18. They are incredible women with decades of experience who have trained hundreds of teachers around the world. They are Patricia Wallner, Madlena Ulrich, Carla Foster, and Jenny Marie Hรถglund. ๐Ÿ’› ๐Ÿ’› ๐Ÿ’›

PDF Versions | 0-3 | 3-6 | 6-12 | 12-18

freedom & limits in the first 3 years of life

notes from Patricia Wallner’s lecture

  • The ages 0-6 and 12-18 are stages of creation – during which freedom and limits are necessary for the formation of the individual.
  • Freedom is something everyone wants – economic freedom, professional freedom, spiritual freedomโ€ฆ. But we cannot do anything we want without consequences. The limits are those that we accept within our community (family, school, neighborhood…world) and learn to live within.
  • In Montessori, as it should be everywhere, the child has the freedom to move, to stay on a task as long as they want, to order one’s own actions, and to develop their will.
  • Of course, as the child’s freedom expands, as do their responsibilities and need for self-discipline, but fundamentally their freedom is of that of the individual to have unlimited possibilities for growth and improvement. This freedom should be the basis of human society.

The only true freedom for an individual is to have opportunity to act independently.โ€

– Dr. Maria Montessori, Education and Peace, chapter 7

  • Adolescents have the freedom to develop into a fully functioning, independent adult. This is a process which begins in the first 3 years of life. 
  • The toddler’s journey to freedom begins at birth. The toddler has the freedom to work with their hands, to find functional independence, to do practical life tasks, to fall asleep when they are tired. There are built-in social limits to learning how to be social, but within those limits – there is a lot of freedom.
  • The child does everything to become an individual of their time and place. 
  • Everything is tied by protective laws which render freedom possible. Fish are the most free of the living beings in the world, yet they cannot get out of the water. 
  • Dr. Montessori describes physical freedom as to be free from the teacher and the parent, free of being under constant influence of another person. They must be free from being dependent. Dependence destroys personality. {Education and Peace}

Organic freedom in necessary to sustain physical freedom (maintaining and sustaining the body).

Then psychic freedom becomes possible. For this an education which follows the laws of development is required with a guide who knows what is psychologically appropriate for each plane and how and when to work with them through each milestone.

Then comes intellectual freedom which is spiritual and intellectual independence, or the birth of the adult.

  • Freedom is an exercise of the the will, making choices based on understanding. But freedom is not a gift to the child from the adult, but the child’s own conquest.
  • Nature provides babies with a vital impulse that drives them. The parent is happy to do everything for them, but the baby fights to roll over, to pull up over and over, without anyone telling them to.
  • The child in their first 3 years of life is called the unconscious creator – one who doesnโ€™t know that they are learning. Gradually the reasoning mind catches up with the unconscious mind and from 4 years old, the child is guided by the reason. The reasoning mind is present from birth, but it is not in control. The child develops it through living and building their knowledge, knowledge they start absorbing in the womb.
  • The vital impulse driving the 0-3 child to learn is called their Hormic will. This and their Absorbent Mind allow the child to incarnate everything they need to learn and everything we want them to learn, such as the rules of life and language.
  • How the child is born and raised will always be the most comfortable way for them to live because this is what they have incarnated. They will learn more through life, but nothing will have the same long term impact like the unprejudiced way in which they absorb their own culture, for example.
  • When parents teach rules by saying โ€œNo! Stop!,” this is the way they will teach rules to others. Active discipline is when the child is in control of themself – when they are internally motivated to follow the rules. 0-3 year old children donโ€™t understand the whole world, so parents still need to give the rules so the child can adapt to wherever they were born (language, habits, food, climateโ€ฆ.). The child is open to everything and develops their own discipline. The adults in their life have to model everything the way we want them to do it. 
  • Children watch us all the time. They have 86 billion neurons. They are listening even when you whisper. The Absorbent Mind takes in everything. Children repeat what we say. Thatโ€™s why even as an adult, you might find yourself saying something your mother always said to you, even without intending to. You incarnated that as a child. 

You have to set limits, giving just enough information so the child knows what you are talking about. ‘You must walk inside. We can run outside later.’

โ€œDo not fear to destroy evil. It is only the good that we must NOT destroy.โ€ – Dr. Montessori

โ€œIf there is some child who persistently annoys the others, the most practical thing to do is to interrupt them.โ€ (Dr. Montessori, The Absorbent Mind, ch. 27)

“A childโ€™s liberty should have as its limit the interests of the group to which he belongs. We should prevent a child from doing anything which may offend or hurt others or which is impolite or unbecoming.” (Dr. Montessori, Discovery of the Child, ch. 3)

Donโ€™t allow child to MISUSE the materials. Allow them to USE the materials.

Be aware of how you stop chaos. Act. Donโ€™t react. 

Adults can make strong connections too, even without the Absorbent Mind. The way you interact with children will get stronger and stronger with practice. Teach yourself to use certain phraseology. Adjust yourself to the childโ€™s level. You wonโ€™t have to think about it. Train yourself to interact in the right way and model correctly when you are with the child. 

Babies CAN concentrate. As long as they have the right materials in front of them. 

โ€œLet us remember that inner discipline is something to come, and not something already present. Our task is to show they way top discipline. Discipline is born with the child concentrates his attention on some object that attracts him.โ€ (Dr. Montessori, The Absorbent Mind, ch. 26)

  • Toddlers need more time to process information than other age groups because their language is more limited than other ages. You can only say one thing to them at a time, no sequences. Speak slowly. When you put on coats, donโ€™t talk about where you are going, wait until you are on the way. Give information and repeat it. 

    Letโ€™s go downstairsโ€ฆโ€ฆ We need coats โ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ. Which hat do you want to wear?โ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ. Letโ€™s go to Grandmaโ€™s houseโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ.. Do you want to walk or ride in the wagon? 
  • Not every child in the world has to look at you while you are speaking. You should know if they are paying attention, whether they are looking at you or not. That is an archaic Western tradition. 
  • Around 2 years old, the child is completely separate from the parent and the Ego is formed. Their favourite word is ‘No’. They want to be heard. They want to have a say in everything.
    You can put on your coat. Or I will help you put on your coat.
    NOT Put on your coat or I will leave without you. (Then you will have to actually leave without them. Which you wonโ€™t do. So you will lose your credibility.)
    This only applies to children under 3.
  • What do you do if the child rejects your idea? You have to set the limit. Tell them nicely:
    Please stop kicking the wall. Either you stop kicking the wall, or I will help you move away.
    Speak to the child the way you would want someone to tell you to stop kicking the wall if you were having an emotional breakdown.
  • Set rules simply by saying:
    We donโ€™t climb on the table.
    We donโ€™t run in the kitchen.
  • With a toddler who can understand more complex language: set the limit, explain the choices, think the situation through, and assist the child to comply.

More about Patricia Wallner’s work HERE


freedom & limits from 3-6 years old

notes from Madlena Ulrich’s lecture

  • In order to be able to follow limits and show responsibility, the child must develop the will so they can relate to the rules that are applied to our group.
  • The will is the desire or inclination to do something. Willpower and will are often used interchangeably, but they are different.
  • Will is the inclination but will power is the power to direct the will to do something or continue to do something in the face of hinderances or distractions.
  • When we do something “of our own free will” it means that we have done it voluntarily and it also means we have considered options. Do I do it or not? Exercising your will means you have considered options and have made a choice.
  • Self control is the ability to regulate your thoughts and behaviour in the face of temptations. We have the ability as adults to give ourselves little rewards if we show signs of self-control. If I do that, then I can do this. Before I watch the news, I will finish this assignment. After I finish this task, then I will have a cup of tea. You use the will to push away distraction, but still require a reward after.
  • Being strong-willed is sometimes considered to be a negative trait by adults when a child is not doing what the adult wants them to do, if a child does the opposite of what we want or is hard to direct and need rewards or punishment to do what the adult wants them to do. However, we also admire people with a strong will, those who have risen above society.
  • Montessori thought a strong will is a positive thing. It means that you have a strong connection to your own will and your own needs, whereas a child with a weak will might allow themselves be guided and and will follow their peers or obey orders.
  • In Montessori we believe that we should help the child to develop their will, to become in charge of their own actions, to be able to stop themselves from doing what they are not supposed to do and challenge themselves to do what they must.

Practical Application:

  • Lots of children’s games are about training the will and executive functions.
  • The Montessori classroom allows the child to be able to focus on what is essential and to be able to adjust their own feelings and emotions.
  • We use our will to calm ourselves down and to wake ourselves up and to adjust.
  • We encourage the children to practice creative problem solving. What is plan b.,c., and d. and how can I adjust?
  • The child should learn to trust themselves and to build their self-esteem. Without self-esteem the child might not act upon the will. Strengthening their will power builds resilience, allowing them to continue their work even when they make mistakes.
  • The child needs to have a feeling that they are doing something deeply meaningful.
  • Babies canโ€™t control their emotions and need to build up these skills in order to regulate their actions in 3-6.
  • During the first year of life, the child doesnโ€™t have control over their hormone system. Their sense of external feeling of safety is given to them by the adults in their environment, for example the calming and singing voice of their father.
  • When they become toddlers they begin to learn how to be aware of and regulate their emotions.
  • At age 2, the will starts to form.
  • We can see that the child’s actions are not based purely on impulse, but on a decision. Now that the child has found their will, they exert it as much as they can. For a toddler itโ€™s new and they donโ€™t know where or how to use it. They tend to over-use it. They say “no” to every question. This is actually a very important stage.
  • At this beautiful and exciting stage, the child is becoming aware that they have a will. It feels to them like they could change the whole world with the word ‘no’. The child with their new power needs to practice the use of their will. This coincides with the maturation of the prefrontal cortex. I want a cookie but my parents told me that I can only have a cookie after dinner. 
  • A childโ€™s development in this area is very dependent on the caregiver. The child may have a strong will but it is still hard work to use that will in the face of temptation. Itโ€™s even hard for some adults.
  • Practical life activities provide the 2-3 year old child with the intelligent direction of movement. These materials are essential in the development of the will. I am moving my hands over the table with the soapy water to eventually cover the whole table with suds. I am building the pink tower by moving one block at a time. I am going to continue scrubbing that whole table until its washed and then I will continue tidying up until everything is back on the shelf.

Support the child’s will with enthusiasm.

Give the child time to make their decisions and donโ€™t give too many choices. 

Obedience:

  • Obedience is the ability to regulate yourself and to follow the needs or requests of someone else.
  • Blind obedience is not a good thing. But the child must learn a willingness to listen to others, consider what they say, and decide whether or not they should act upon what they said. Obedience really means that the child knows they need to do something and they can do it, even if they don’t want to because they know that it is important. My teacher says we need to tidy up our work – I donโ€™t really want to, but I know itโ€™s true.

Levels of obedience:

  • level 1: the child obeys if their needs are in accordance with the requests.
  • level 2: the child obeys as long as you donโ€™t turn your back.
  • level 3: the child obeys without being asked, because he sees the needs.

Development of the will:

  • level 1: instinctual behaviour of the newborn that needs the adult to build up the ability to self-regulate
  • level 2: deliberate action when the child starts noticing the needs of other and occasionally acts upon them โ€ฆ if they feel so inclined at the moments and then around 2 it turns more into internal motivation.
  • level 3: the child becomes aware of the impact of his actions on the environment. If I push my friends while we are standing in line something unpleasant will happen and thatโ€™s not positive so I am checking myself even though I am impatient right now.

When the child is not doing what we want, we must consider which stage the child is in the development of obedience and their will. that development and ask ourselves, “Do my wishes line up with that childโ€™s?” Some children have been given very little opportunity to regulate their will. For example, some adults think that a little child should not have to struggle with are putting on their socks or putting their own work away. This child may consequently have a delay in their development of will and obedience.

Respect childโ€™s pace.

Respect childโ€™s ability to self-correct and to build self-confidence and resilience.

Observe.

Respect the childโ€™s concentration.

More about Madlena’s work HERE


freedom & limits from 6-12 years old

notes from Carla Foster’s lecture

  • We are responsible for our freedom.
  • Dr. Montessori defines freedom as an environment which is conducive to the most perfect conditions and the freedom which allows life to develop.
  • If this is not obtained, then the child’s adaptation is based on captivity.
  • Experiment:
    Teachers went to children in small group and asked the children what they thought freedom meant. The children had a primitive understanding that it is just doing what they want. We thought about what assumptions were the teachers making when they say you have freedom here as long as you take responsibility. They hadnโ€™t talked to the children about what lies beneath that freedom and responsibility concept.
  • Children need activities that require effort. With every gained trained movement, you gain a freedom of movement. Itโ€™s always effort even when itโ€™s easy.
  • For the child of 6 years old, much of their learning has seemed effortless. They seem to have forgotten all the times they fell down when they were learning to walk.
  • We often forget all the effort we went through to learn what we have. Now this current effort is tiresome, because I am conscious of this effort and it seemed effortless before. But this consciousness of their effort brings them to a new level of responsibility the ability to plan.
  • Planing brings the potential of purpose.
  • Thereโ€™s also considerations to take: people, time, constraints, resources.
  • Talking to the children about effort, purpose, and consideration is perhaps more fruitful than talking to them about responsibility.
  • In the second plane there are emerging characteristics that help them to answer the question, “why are we here?”
  • They become aware of laws like gravity that they must adhere to.
  • The child has a lot of work to do in just 6 years in order to do all the things that an adolescent can.
  • Now we have a world economy and a literate society a world that demands much more than our brains were designed to handle. We canโ€™t abandon this because it is us. Now we have to teach children to read and write, but the child is in this realm of adapting to the world. WE have to be much more creative than the institution of education has ever been to make ourselves stuarts of the earth and units of humanity.
  • Each of the human tendencies active on the second plane has a practical and a spiritual manifestation – not just will or obedience, but the practical application of them.
  • Responsibility is not discipline. Freedom is not a reward for obedience.
  • We must not have just a friendly attitude toward error but we have to embrace error.
  • We must pay attention to the needs of the environment and the needs of ourselves.
  • As adults we can keep on working and finding these strengths that we received from nature at around 6 years old and build on them. 
  • These strengths appear as fragile potential, not as full-blown skills. We must help the child develop these skills.
  • You will have very few rules in your classroom and they will be organic.
  • If you are constantly making more rules, you are youโ€™re on the wrong path. You need to be releasing rules and promoting effort, purpose, and consideration.

The child at 6-12 is a robust explorer. They are learning about courage and fear, they challenge, they distance themselves from family.

  • This can be frustrating for the family. Trying to get away from family, having all this energy at school and struggling to be contained inside is a sign that they are being limited in their space.
  • Thereโ€™s a thrill in going out into the unknown and experiencing fear. For the 6-12 year old it is strange to feel mixed emotions. Being courageous is not without fear.
  • Curiosity can be an antidote to fear. Let’s get curious and ask questions. Let’s love our environment. That helps us get up in the morning and conquer our fear of the next morning or the next year.
  • Packing, planning, organising with the peer group can be an antidote to fear. This makes it obvious to be a robust explorer.
  • The world is so complex now and the guidelines are not clear. WE need to make the childโ€™s path clearer for them.
  • Children need challenge. They need different kinds of challenges and they need to reflect on different kinds of challenges, talk to someone they donโ€™t know very well, take a role they havenโ€™t filled before, learn about challenges, face challenges, and discover the purpose of challenge. 

  • Without the absolute natural laws there is no freedom. Laws are foundational to existence. This makes a child curious: if a snowflake needs laws to exist then what laws do I need in order to exist? Thatโ€™s why Iโ€™m here: to develop myself according to these laws. I must develop my body and mind to ask the why and find the answers.
  • Imagination becomes really important. We unite the how and why with imagination to talk about early humans. We say to the children: we humans are like this because this is what humans are. You have the same creativity that the first inventors had. 
  • Reason and imagination are not just there suddenly. They have been growing through the first plane out of the home.
  • Time becomes important. How humans have always considered, wondered about and measured time in different ways. We have always been obsessed with time.
    What does it mean to live and grow and die?
    We have been making stories about this forever and ever. WE must help the children to face this so instead of taking the time away from them because we think they need endless time but put them into a flow that helps them understand what times passing means.
  • We start at 6 years old by thinking, “what does time passing mean?”. We write down the times and discuss what a child has done in a specific quantity of time.
  • They donโ€™t have endless time; they have 6 years. A child doesnโ€™t know what their own pace is until they are challenged.

We donโ€™t talk about children working at their own pace because that is a synonym for having endless time, which is an escape.

We talk about effort, purpose and consideration. 

  • We talk to the child: What steps have you taken? Are you ready for the next step?
  • We donโ€™t tie them down to a particular thing. Okay, youโ€™re interested in planets, you go look at planets and weโ€™ll come back in a couple days and discuss what you can do with this. Now you want to do a play. Okay.
  • For 6 year olds, things just grow and at some point they just stop. The child writes “…the end” if they just get tired of writing. In this case, donโ€™t tell the child to go back and revise. The skill of revision comes later. Let them be done. When they are ready to revise things, then you can encourage them to revise.
  • They will emerge their desired project but it will not come out immediately. WE have to help them with their own process.
  • We have to talk with the child about all the work they did, how they divided the labor, how they made a problem to find the solution, what happens when we kept our materials in order and were able to cooperate and reflect….. If we don’t do thes then the child doesnโ€™t see the efforts they have made. This is the Big Work – this is them owning their own efforts, purpose, and consideration. Then the child can mobilise their will for the next challenge. 
  • Monotonous repetition kills will.
  • Repetition is important, but monotony makes the child avoid work, initiative, and challenge.
  • We need to minimise control of error and become our own controls of error. That went really wrong lets figure out why.
  • The child is exploring awe and wonder. They have complex emotions about feeling small, yet significant. Plants do amazing things and adapt to the environment. Plants are amazing, and humans are also amazing. Music is amazing…
  • Enjoy the freedom to act independently and to feel awe and wonder.

Justice:

  • We all know a child who thinks that if they lost a game then the game was unfair.
  • Distributive justice is good for mathematical division but not great for social cohesion. A 9 or 10 year old, thinking like this is not prepared for society.
  • Children can understand if you explain the different ideas of fairness to them, the distribution of equity to help some correct a disadvantage/ to make the playing field more equal.
  • Restorative justice is when a child sees that if they make a mistake or wrong someone, they can make it right again. Most society believe that if someone wrongs us than an external party will make it right. But we must help the children keep the idea of interpersonal experiences. Give the child time to cool off, mobilise the reasoning mind, and consider what needs to be done in order for the relationship to build back stronger. 
  • These discussions increase children’s freedom and responsibility.
  • Discuss what communities they are a part of, what does being a part of that community does for them and what do they do for their community. When you discuss the classroom community it becomes apparent that there are a lot of things they can do to be a part of their communities.
  • We must create opportunities for a child to find new parts to play and contributions to make to their community.
  • When a childโ€™s behaviour shows limited experience, it makes it apparent to the adult that they are in a cage. 
  • Sometimes we have this idea that a child should never be evaluated or self-evaluate negatively. But the child is always evaluating and comparing themselves to others, so we must help them to do it honestly.
  • Help a child recognise their issue or stuck point and then inquire if they need help with it.
  • Help the child understand that whenever you know something, it is your responsibility to share that with the community. I know how to draw a lizard does anyone need a lizard. I know these math facts, I can help with those.
  • When you form groups, keep in mind how each individualโ€™s strength will be revealed and interplay.

Fear is the enemy of freedom and responsibility.

Conflict must not be banished from the classroom because it helps the children understand themselves and others.

Bring the child to a consciousness of his own dignity and he will feel free.

Have a collective goal. Math facts are not just for each individual child. Literacy is not just for each individual child. It is a group effort to propel ourselves froward in unity. 

More about Carla’s work HERE


freedom & limits from 12 – 18 years old

notes from Jenny Marie Hรถglund’s lecture

  • Children from 6-12 years old have a reasoning mind, but abstractly. 
  • Adolescents have a reasoning mind.
  • The child was born into a culture, but now they are born into being part of society and they need to be free from their family.
  • They need a good foundation in first 12 years of life planes, so they are firmly based in their culture. Then they will be separated from their family in order to be able to attach to something else.
  • The environment itself must be changed in order for this attachment to take place.
  • It’s very different from the prepared environment 0-6 and 6-12. They need a mindfully unprepared environment. It must be restricted within certain rules that give the necessary guidance.
  • The adolescent has to discover these rules, supported by the adult, to create their OWN social organisation, community, and ability to work together. This creates their limits. 

The environment must promote not only the freedom of the individual, but also the formation of a society.โ€ – Dr. Maria Montessori, Education and peace, ch. 14

  • Purpose is important because it keeps the adolescent motivated and gives them energy and the opportunity to give their best to others and have a positive impact on their community. This is what they need to experience.
  • They need loyalty. The work is not done until all the work is done. If one finishes one part, you donโ€™t leave your friends, you go to your friends and help them finish their work.
  • It is the work that gives them the energy and knowledge and understanding that they have a common purpose. 

The ownership of accountability:

  • The adolescent is accountable for their choices, work, and responsibilities. The freedom is that of the community, a code of conduct and civility of the social organisation that is set up by the adolescents themselves together to have a harmonious community. 
  • The adolescent learns what freedom is in a social context: the freedom to participate in the social organisation with discipline and accountability.
  • Each adolescent is responsible for themself and their role in the community.
  • A higher self control must happen when you live and work in a group. It isnโ€™t all about the individual anymore and requires more self discipline that develops out of the needs of the group/social organisation. 

In speaking of the [adolescent] child we are now dealing with the manners and rules of social existence, and we come to the need of the laws regulating work and exchangeโ€ฆ.โ€ – Dr. Maria Montessori

  • The child doesnโ€™t have the same kind of responsibilities or consequences as adults. We find this out though observation.
  • Observation has to be done constantly. Adults jump in and interfere constantly because the adult is faster. In order to give the child what they need, we have to step back.
  • For adolescents, we sometimes have to facilitate difficult situations, but usually they sort things out themselves. They only want affirmation and support from the adult. 

One of the things the adult should practice is the observation of different mental states of the child and the actions which accompany them.โ€ – Dr. Maria Montessori, NAMTA Journal

  • We are a source of information to the child on values and language use. We donโ€™t have to use the childโ€™s language. We want to stretch their vocabulary and we want them to feel confident in the adult conversations they will have and in academic environments.
  • We offer them demonstrations so they can become independent of the adult and feel capable in an adult setting. 
  • The adolescents have a community meeting every week, which is a formal meeting with a set agenda with a chairperson and secretary. They can venture issues, discuss rules they come up with, discuss problems, discuss moral dilemmas, come to consensuses with guidance for their community…
  • Through literature or reading seminars, they find out about the adult world and themselves. They ask questions about human interactions and what can be behind different moral codes.
  • While they are reading a novel they can explore their own value system to see if it agrees with the characters in the novel.
  • The adult must be very observant of the relationships, interactions, and language in the community. You may say to an adolescent โ€œIf I were you, I would rephrase that.โ€
  • If an adolescent is being rejected by the group, it needs to be addressed by the child, with the support of the adults. The adult helps the adolescent to be aware of their choices and that they are accountable for their actions.
  • Discipline is not imposed by the adult, but they are reminded of it by their peers.
  • Limits are not set by the adults, but by the adolescents themselves depending on their expectations of themselves as members of a community. The adult gives a framework for them to set limits.
  • Setting limits with adolescents is different because you canโ€™t pick up a teenager off the table if they put their feet up on the table! You donโ€™t have to do anything, but the school manager could take the table away as a consequence. They need to respect their space. If they respect the space, they wonโ€™t put their feet on the table.
  • We have to know when to intervene and when to wait. Limited intervention by the adult, is a Montessori pillar. Maria Montessori is very clear about when to do that.
  • HOW to do that requires practice and learning. Maria Montessori is clear that we need to have expectations and know what they are and parents need to have the same expectations in the family, as do the teachers in a class.
  • Adolescents know their parents well. They know which parent to speak to about what. Never be afraid of saying “NO” when no is needed. If you donโ€™t say ‘no’ when needed, you are abandoning the child. 
  • The adolescent needs adult work – not only practical life like baking and cleaning – they have been doing that for 12 years, creating their potential. Now they need to realise their potential. Their work needs to be relevant to their life.
  • The mathematics need to be applied. If their schoolwork is not relevant or applicable to their life, they will not be interested in it. They need to b able to use the information they are learning. 
  • The freedom of the community now overrides the freedom of the individual. They need to run their own community life. And the roll of the adult is to help them to do it by themselves. Help us to do it by ourselves.
  • The adult needs to decide if they are ready to allow their child this freedom. 
  • Freedom is not a reward. It is not something that can be earned. (For example, when you are done, you mayโ€ฆ.) This kind of freedom is conditional, but in Montessori, our goal is for the child to have active freedom of choice. This will allow the adolescent to live their life to their highest potential. 
  • The child needs to be challenged in order to change themselves and adapt. But this is not a freedom from conditions, but the freedom to take a stand from the conditions that you face.
  • Work has to be there, but there also has to be a social context. When the adolescents live, work, and study together, they experience that they have a duty that comes with the freedom. They have a new awareness. They had one individual life, but now they have a group awareness and a duty to society. 
  • Adolescents plan projects in their community meetings. So much happens through dialogue. Their plans are supported by the adult with their adult experience. We support the adolescent to understand possible consequences because they are very optimistic.
  • They learn to make choices and they learn to think about the things that matter. Some choices are significant or insignificant. The adolescent may feel ask, “what difference will it make in 100 years?” They start to pay more attention to what does matter and less attention to what doesnโ€™t.
  • Their freedom is a conquest, a point of arrival, not a point of departure.
  • Freedom allows children to enjoy their environment to the fullest. discipline can turn this enthusiasm into motivation to explore deeper worlds they hadnโ€™t thought of before. Freedom and discipline are beautiful friends. 
  • There is a difference between “freedom FROM” and a “freedom TO”: the freedom from is coercion; the freedom to shapes one’s own life and give it significance. 
  • Adolescents need freedom from their parents. They still love them, but they need to increase their self-respect, confidence, and participation in society. 

The child is the victim of events but have the clarity of vision to direct and shape the gutter of human society.” – Dr. Maria Montessori, Education for a New World, introduction

Adults get so involved in their own self-importance and adult attitude, but please try to practice self-discipline. Act as if you are being observed every moment by a child and do your best to practice self awareness and social awareness.

Even when you are alone, try to practice the same freedom and limits with yourself that we expect for the child. If you finish your work, look around to see if anyone else needs help. If you want to go to your sports practice, but your husband is overwhelmed with his studies, then perhaps stay home to cook dinner for your family, without even mentioning the sports practice. 

More about Jenny’s work HERE


Thank you for reading!

Parent Information

Fatherhood Interview with Chad


For our podcast I did an interview with Chad about fatherhood! Here is what he shared with me about his personal experience about becoming a father and discovering the kind of parent he wanted to be. There is a lot of talk of fathers and mothers and breaking traditional roles and stereotypes. This is a very emotional topic and one that carries centuries of gender-based biases. There are also so many personal, religious, cultural, familiar, and social factors that contribute to the experience of every parent and of course there are all kinds of family models. Chad shares his experience of becoming a father to one child, as a man who is married to a woman (the Montessori Mother, no less ๐Ÿ™‚ and who was raised by very strong, Alaskan women. As Chad shared with me, although every parent’s journey is distinct, it is helpful to hear about each other’s experiences and this can affect our understanding of what being a father means to us.

Introduction

Chad is a Montessori father and teacher for 3-6 year olds. Together he and I run our school and raise our 2-year-old daughter. Chad also guides Fathersโ€™ Meet-Ups, which is what inspired us to do this podcast episode/blog post.

What is Fathers Meet-up?

Once a month on a Saturday fathers come and have a space to interact with their children and we have a discussion, which is optional. Some fathers just want to spend time with their children, which is great. The reason I came up with the idea is because I saw that in our classes there were loads of women who would talk to each other about their experience as parents and as women and how that in many ways helped them. It made me think that fathers donโ€™t really talk about these things. Thereโ€™s not really a platform where they can feel like they wonโ€™t be judged or they can express themselves honestly without hurting someoneโ€™s feelings. We have this environment where all different kinds of fathers can share the way they feel about things without fearing someone is going to judge them. Even if they disagree, itโ€™s even better that way because a lot of fathers do have different experiences and can share that and it expands our understanding.ย 

All fathers are welcome with children from 2 months to 4 years. Some fathers talk about how their religion affects their parenting, but itโ€™s not religion-specific. There is also talk of mothers and wives as well as husbands and partner-fathers, we also have single fathers and co-parenting fathers. It all plays into the idea that we get together and we hear about eachother’s experiences and this can deeply affect our understanding of what kind of fathers we want to be and how we understand what being a father means, particularly to us.ย 

What changed for you when you became a father?

I think becoming a father opened my eyes a lot –  to the biological truths about ageing, family, the unfairness of how women are treated, and fatherhood. I think itโ€™s made me feel more in-touch with other men. I was raised by only women and I always felt a bit out of place among men. My mom was a tough lady who worked in the oil fields her whole life after she left the army.  She taught me how to use a chainsaw and build houses so I ended up doing a lot of jobs in traditionally male environments for most of my life and I always felt apart, even though I was competent within that world. Becoming a father made me see the parts of me that are masculine and because of that I felt more comfortable in male surroundings and maybe more empathetic to other men and more conscious of what we as men in society really need in order to be more present with our children. 

What to you hope fathers will get out of Fathers Meet-Up?

Having a place where fathers can share their experiences and get or give advice is a very important reason I see to be a part of our group. More importantly, I set this whole thing because so many fathers just donโ€™t have equal time with their children. There are a myriad of reasons, but I like the idea that on a Saturday a father and his child can set out on an adventure across the city and have a place to go that the other partner knows is safe. Everyone who works with children has a different way of doing it and they are all valid as long as they can provide for the childโ€™s mental, emotional, and physical needs. What often happens when both parents are together with the child, or when one parent doesnโ€™t get any alone time with the child, is that the rhythm of one parent begins to control the rhythm of the other parent – or even excludes it unintentionally. So I think itโ€™s vital for a dad and his child to set off into the world, just the two of them, and solve problems as they come.ย 

What was the best piece of advice you have received from another parent?ย 

I suppose the best advice that Iโ€™ve gotten was from a man who was in the playground by himself with his children and I was talking to him while I was with my child and he expressed to me the idea about the rhythms. He understood later when his child was older that itโ€™s really important to be alone with your child in order to develop communication. He said that a father needs to spend time alone with his children as early as possible. This means that he sometimes has to put his foot down and say, ‘I am a part of my childโ€™s life and that means now, not later when they can talk and play football, but now.’

What is a common misunderstanding about fatherhood and what is the truth that you now know?ย 

I think this is my experience, I donโ€™t know if itโ€™s everyoneโ€™s, but I think that a big myth is that raising children is ‘womenโ€™s work.โ€™ We live in a time that is very different from past generations and many fathers are a big part of their childrenโ€™s lives. However, I see very prevalently in society the belief that men are not natural parents. Iโ€™ve seen a woman jump across isles thinking I was going to drop my child. I see women who feel the need to explain how a stroller works to me or whether or not I should consult my childโ€™s mother before I give them ibuprofen. Itโ€™s not that women donโ€™t suffer degradation in society, but itโ€™s particularly difficult for men to surpass this misconception thatย  โ€œmother knows bestโ€. Fathers are often not considered as equal parents with an equal right to make decisions or have their own philosophy for child-raisingโ€ฆ [Chad gives several of examples in the podcast about common situations he has heard of and how the father felt when being corrected in those situations]

Maybe it looks easy when a mother does it, but there is no magic โ€œmotherโ€™s touchโ€. Itโ€™s not about being a mother. When two human beings suffer through difficulty- and being a child is extremely difficult with a myriad of new experiences – they develop trust with each other and a form of communication thatโ€™s only between them. The child understands that they are safe with this person physically and emotionally. Women have the benefit of countless generations who have come before them that cemented this role of motherhood in society. They also passed down tools of how to care for another human being, which many men are not given when they are boys.ย 

Do you feel like fathers have equal opportunities in education and parenting? What do we need to change to help them be more included?ย 

I think fathers often donโ€™t have the level of opportunity as mothers do and I think itโ€™s really about time. Many fathers donโ€™t have the particular kind of courage or tact to put their foot down and say ‘I am an equal parent. And while I may not be the only one making the rules of engagement, I wonโ€™t be left out of the conversation or subordinated to carrying out orders.’ I donโ€™t know how that comes off, but when youโ€™re a father it does often feel like โ€˜I just have to carry out what the mother says because mother knows best and I am just kind of hereโ€ฆโ€™ A mother needs support, but a father also has valid input. Once a man has crossed over their line of illumination and their presence in the childโ€™s life becomes vital, a lot of it becomes easier.

I will not listen to what society tells me and I will be present in my childโ€™s daily life somehow…I will do this no matter what anyone else on the planet says. I am my childโ€™s parent for life.โ€ย 

Fathers often have a stack of difficulties. Some may only need time alone with their children to figure things out. Sometimes the other partner needs to see things from their point of view and ensure that their own behaviour is not discouraging or disabling that father from being present. Often schedules can be rearranged. [Examples in the podcast]

The priority we give our children now is the priority that they will give us when we are old and we donโ€™t have work or our health and all we have is time.

Parenting is dominated by a feminine aesthetic and it can be intimidating for men to enter that world of holding the baby or of changing diapers or of putting their baby in a carrier and going for a walk quietly. It can make a man feel emasculated or like theyโ€™re in a world that they donโ€™t fit into, or they feel awkward in. I donโ€™t think many women are cognisant of the fact that this feminine aesthetic makes men feel out of place. There is a lot behind that psychologically, but the essential point is that a partner who is more comfortable with parentingย can maybe try to see things from the other parentโ€™s point of view. Maybe the kind of encouragement that they are trying to give isnโ€™t the right kind. Maybe choosing a different tact in conversing or commenting on how they are with the child could be worked on.ย 

ย How did you learn about what kind of father you wanted to be?ย 

I never really thought of myself as a father. Maybe in my mid do late twenties I thought it would be cool to have a child, but it was only in passing moments. I think society doesnโ€™t really gear us (men) toward what kind of fathers we want to be, especially not in the way that women are geared towards it. I was raised by women and the closest thing I ever had to a father was Indiana Jones as a kind of childhood idol. So many fathers base their idea of what kind of father they want to be simply on doing the exact opposite than what their father did. We have to think about and be aware of the fact that fatherhood doesnโ€™t really have any good role-models.ย 

The tools that we need to be a functioning member of our family in todayโ€™s world, to care for and encourage another human being, were not given to us. We have to forge them from scratch, from zero, through our own experiences in every moment.

What is the best part of being a father?

I think the best part of being a father – and this is going to sound strange or maybe silly – but when I pick up my daughter from somewhere, she catches sight of me and her whole face lights up and she runs towards me and hugs me, I think something inside me just melts. It kind of feels like all those fears that you are doing something wrong, that every parent goes though, just goes away because you see that your child is happy to see you.


Thank you for reading!

-Katelynn & Chad

Parent Information, The Montessori Method

Language Development


In this blog post you will learn the stages of development for language comprehension and speech from pregnancy to 6 years old; I share some ways to help your child learn and use language by making small changes to every-day interactions; and I reference recent, peer-reviewed studies to answer the main questions I hear from parents:
1. When to children learn to talk?
2. Will having more than one language at home cause speech delays? 
3. My child isnโ€™t talking yet. Should I be worried?
4. How can I teach my child a new language?
5. What is the best way to support language learning in general?
6. Should I try baby sign language?

#1 When do children learn to talk?

ages & stages

  • Research has shown that language learning starts in the womb and could start as early as the 4th month of pregnancy, from the time Baby is able to hear. {1,2}
  • As seen in the guides below, much of language-learning occurs during the pre-linguistic stage from pregnancy to the time child speaks their first, intentional word. 
  • In general, the child says their first word around the age of 1. By the age of 3 the child is able to speak in short sentences. 
  • Some babies may start speaking earlier, and some toddlers may start later. Every child has their own, perfect timing.
  • In the 2nd year of life there is an explosion of language during which the child learns approximately 7-10 new words per day, or 1 new word every 2 waking hours!

For a complete guide of speech development, you can open and print our new language development chart:
0-1 year | 1-6 years | complete 0-6 guide

#2 Will having more than one language at home cause speech delay? 

This is a myth!

  • The saying that teaching a child multiple languages will cause delayed speech is a myth! 
  • In fact, in the first three years of life children can learn multiple languages at the same speed as a child who is only learning one. 
  • There is no limit to the number of languages a child can learn in the first 6 years of life. See #4 How to teach my child a new language below.
  • Having two or more native languages has long been proven to be linked to higher executive function and cognitive abilities. Specifically, multilingualism is linked to longer attention-span, higher task-switching ability, and protection against cognitive decline in old age. {recent peer-reviewed studies: 7, 8}
  • The connection between multiple languages and speech delays may be relevant in combination with other factors such as family history, medical conditions, low parent education, and lack of stimulation. If you are interested in this topic, here are two recent case studies on the risk factors of speech delays. {3, 4}

#3 My child isnโ€™t talking yet. Should I be worried?

  • In the first year of life, the development of language involves mostly learning language comprehension, which is neurological. The development of speech foremost depends on motor ability, which is still developing from 0-2 years old. To produce speech, the child must first have the motor skills to form sounds. Secondly the child requires the neurodevelopment to absorb words and concepts through visual/auditory/sensory information, comprehend and process that information, formulate language in the brain, and ultimately express it. Each of these processes occur in a different area of the brain. {5}
  • I share this with you to show that a childโ€™s first word is a huge task which the child has been working on for nearly their entire life up to that moment.
  • An 18 month-old child may be able to say 1-15 words, but also comprehends 70-100 words as well as grammar, intonation, and โ€œyesโ€/โ€œnoโ€. 

speech delays

  • If your child is not yet speaking in 3- word sentences by the age of 3, this could a sign of a speech delay. 
  • If your child is over 3 and you are concerned about a speech delay, seek advice from your childโ€™s paediatrician and/or a speech pathologist.
  • If your child is under 3 years old, but you are worried about speech delays, you can have your childโ€™s hearing checked, monitor other developmental milestones, learn ways to support early childhood language development, and speak with your childโ€™s pediatrician. 
  • Many babies and toddlers start speaking later. This is not by itself a sign that something is wrong. However, speech delays are not something to be afraid of. For more information on what a speech delay can indicate and what to expect if your child has a speech delay, here is a helpful parent guide. {6}

#4 How can I teach my child a new language?

one-person-one language

  • In Montessori we aim to support the childโ€™s amazing ability to absorb and learn to perfection multiple language without direct instruction. The rule we follow is one-face-one-language, meaning that each person in the childโ€™s life speaks only one language directly to the child. 
  • In early childhood language is learned through absorption by contact with another person who speaks directly to the learner. 
  • The adult does not need to speak their own native language, but a language they are comfortable speaking and able to speak consistently to the child. Choose the language you want your child to learn from you and use that when you are together. 
  • In groups or family settings where the language is different, you can speak the group language, which is the culturally considerate thing to do. But when you are speaking only to your child, you would switch back to the language you share together.
  • In this way, the child is able to clearly organise and learn the language completely and they are also able to organise and separate languages associated with different people. For example, the child knows that their mother and grandmother call this fruit an apple, and their friends and teacher call this fruit der Apfel.

changing the language you speak to your child

  • If a parent would like to change the primary language they speak with the child, it is possible to switch as long as they are consistent from then on. For example, if a parent has multiple native languages themselves and decides later that they would like to introduce a different language from their partner, itโ€™s not too late!
  • It is best to make this switch as early as possible. 
  • What to expect: 
    > Switching during the pre-linguistic stage, or during the first year of life, is a smooth transition in my experience and in my observations. 
    > If you make the switch after the first year, or during the linguistic stage, it may take several days to a week for both parent and child to adjust. 
    > If your child is over 2 years old and is already in their explosion of language, this change will be more challenging, but it is still possible. 
    > After 6 years old, changing the primary language you speak with your child is not likely to be successful. If you know of a situation when this was possible for a family, please email me! I would love to know more.  
  • To help your child learn this new language, see #5 What is the best way to help my child learn language? below.

See the language development guide for reference of your childโ€™s stage of language-learning.

establish a personal connection to the target language

If you want to teach your child a language which is different from your primary language with them, here are some ideas:

  • Find a class in your area which is taught in the target language: Montessori in English, Ballet in Spanish, Art in French, etc. to normalise the language and allow the child to absorb it naturally in a fun environment. 
  • As often as possible speak to friends, caregivers, other parents, etc. in the target language while the child is present in order to make the target language a normal part of the environment. 
  • Find a babysitter or playgroup leader who speaks the target language, so your child can create a personal connection to the adult speaking the language to them. 
  • Read books in the target language to your little one. 
  • You can read to your child in any language, regardless of what language you usually speak together. The book should be read only in the language it is written in. In this situation, the rule is one-book-one-language.
  • Listen to songs in the target language and have fun singing and dancing together in that language.

#5 What is the best way to support language learning in general?

For specific recommendations for your childโ€™s current stage of development, see the Language Development Guide. Below you will find general recommendations for giving language to toddlers in daily life, in the way you play with your child, and while you are out and about together. 

daily life

  • Use body language when you speak to the child. Get down on their level, make eye contact, and show them what you are talking about. Pause for comprehension, and repeat if needed.
    For example: if you want to ask if they are hungry, bring the snack to them. Get down on their level, make eye contact and ask, โ€œAre you hungry?โ€ Showing them the food. Pause for an answer. โ€œLetโ€™s go eat at the table,โ€ and point to the table.
  • Speak in complete sentences with descriptive vocabulary. For example:
    Say โ€œHave you hurt yourself?โ€ Not โ€œBaby ow?โ€
  • Instead of โ€œyayโ€ or โ€œuh ohโ€ describe what your baby has done/observed. โ€œYou put the ball in the basket!โ€ โ€œYour plate fell on the ground.โ€
  • Offer choices, even if your child is not speaking yet. They then have the option to speak or point.
    โ€œDo you want milk or water?โ€ โ€œDo you want to take a bath or read a book first?โ€
  • Add on to the words your child uses, including them in full sentences or offering more information. If your child says, โ€œOutside wet.โ€ You can reply, โ€œYes, it is wet outside. Itโ€™s raining. Can you see the puddles?โ€

the way you play

  • Use complete and correct names for all items, animals, furnitureโ€ฆ
    For example, say โ€œhippopotamusโ€ – notย hippo. Say โ€œcarโ€ – not beep beep. Say โ€œcylinderโ€ – not circle. Say โ€œcatโ€ – not meow meow.
  • Instead of questions like โ€œWhat color is this?/What is this animal?โ€ Ask the child to give you the red block or put the giraffe on the table. By responding choosing the item you asked for, you will know if they know the names of the colors, animals, etc. 
  • When reading books or looking at photos, isolate nouns to teach vocabulary. Instead of โ€œthis is a squirrelโ€, just say SQUIRREL and repeat the word one or two times. 

out and about

  • When you go out to do things with your child, to the park, to the zoo, to a cafe, the child is absorbing a lot of language by just watching and listening. You can connect them to these places and aid their learning by discussing their observations.
  • It is not enough just to take the child to interesting places. You have to make the connection so they can learn how to understand and categorise what they see.
  • On a walk, let your child roam free and notice what draws their attention. If they want to stare at a leaf on the ground for five minutes – great! Letโ€™s talk about the leaf. What tree could it have fallen from? Is it whole or broken? What does the leaf tell us about the season?.โ€ฆ
  • Allow your child to be present for and included in conversations between adults.

#6 Baby Sign Language

  • Baby sign language is a great tool for non-verbal babies and toddlers. It also helps verbal toddlers express themselves when they are across the room from you or in situations when they feel shy and prefer not to speak. 
  • You can start from birth or any time after that to use signs for different things. You can use as few or as many as you want.
  • Any sign you use will work, as long as you are consistent with how you use it. 
  • Here is a free, online dictionary which will shows you the signs in many different countries. 
  • As much as possible, use real signs from your countryโ€™s dialect of sign language. Let the sign language you use with your little one be a real language you are adding to their life!
  • If your child has their own way of making a sign you use, accept and respond to it, so they know you understand. Continue making the sign in the same way that you taught it to them. This is the way they understand it already and the way they are trying to imitate.

my experience with baby sign language: 

When our daughter was born we started using basic signs: milk, diaper change, I love youโ€ฆ But when our baby was eight months old she started repeating the signs. We were so amazed that we incorporated more and more into our language. She still uses them today in combination with spoken words and we are so happy that she has the ability to express herself when she needs something. 

helpful signs

You can look up signs in different countries with a video dictionary such as spreadthesign.com

PAINYou can ask the child if they are feeling pain and they can tell you if they have hurt themselves. This is such a relief when baby cannot yet explain to the parent verbally how they feel.Point your index fingers together and twist your writs in opposite directions.
CHANGE (DIAPER)Make two fists and put them together at the palm. Twist your wrists in opposite directions.
EAT/FOODYour child can tell you when they are hungry and you can tell them when itโ€™s time to eat.Bring your fingers and thumb together on your right hand, moving your hand towards and away from your mouth in a short motion.
SLEEPYour child can tell you when they are tired and you can ask them if they want to sleep or relax. Place an open hand on your cheek.
BUMPYour child can tell you if they have fallen down.Make two fists and bump them together at the thumbs.
MILKMake two fists, opening and closing your hands.
WATERPut your first 3 fingers to your chin, holding your thumb and pinkie together, palm facing to the side.
FINISHED/ALL DONEWith two open hands in front of your chest, face them away from you, then turn them towards you.
WORKYour child can tell others that they are busy or that their toy is not available.Make two fists and cross your forearms over one another.
WASH HANDSMove your hands together as if you are washing them.

Sources

  1. Language experienced in utero affects vowel perception after birth: a two-country study, USA National Library of Medicine, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3543479/
  2. Fetal rhythm-based language discrimination: a biomagnetometry study, NeuroReport Health Journal, https://oce.ovid.com/article/00001756-201708010-00004/HTML
  3. An Assessment of Risk Factors of Delayed Speech and Language in Children: A Cross-Sectional Study, USA National Library of Medicine, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9608900/
  4. Speech and language delay in children: Prevalence and risk factors, USA National Library of Medicine, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6559061/
  5. What brain regions control our language? And how do we know this? The Conversation Academic Journal, https://theconversation.com/what-brain-regions-control-our-language-and-how-do-we-know-this-63318#:~:text=Regions%20in%20your%20frontal,%20temporal,left%20side%20of%20your%20brain
  6. Language Delays in Toddlers: Information for Parents, Healthy Children Medical Blog by the American Academy of Pediatrics, https://www.healthychildren.org/English/ages-stages/toddler/Pages/language-delay.aspx 
  7. Bilingualism and the Development of Executive Function: The Role of Attention, USA National Library of Medicine, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4442091/
  8. Positive Cognitive Effects of Bilingualism and Multilingualism on Cerebral Function: a Review, Psychiatric Quarterly Journal, https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11126-017-9532-9

Thank you for reading!